Thank you for signing!

End Cruelty Disguised As Delicacy — Ban Restaurants From Serving Live Animals

1,679 signatures toward our 30,000 goal

5.596666666666667% Complete

Sponsor: Free The Ocean

New York must end the barbaric practice of serving live animals before more intelligent beings are mutilated in the name of taste.

End Cruelty Disguised As Delicacy — Ban Restaurants From Serving Live Animals

In Queens, New York, diners sit down to a meal that shocks the conscience. At Sik Gaek, a popular restaurant, octopuses are cut apart while still alive and brought to the table with their limbs writhing on the plate1. Customers describe the sensation of tentacles clinging to their mouths as they chew. Staff dismiss this as reflex, but animal welfare experts argue the movement shows the animal was dismembered while alive2.

What is presented as a delicacy is, in fact, cruelty unfolding in plain sight. New York law has no ban on the practice, leaving intelligent, sentient animals to endure excruciating deaths in front of paying customers2.

Sentient Beings Reduced to Spectacle

Octopuses are among the most intelligent animals in the ocean. They use tools, remember experiences, solve complex problems, and even play games3. Scientists confirm they possess nervous systems capable of perceiving pain in ways similar to mammals4. Yet in certain kitchens, these extraordinary beings are treated as props for entertainment, hacked apart piece by piece while still aware of their suffering5.

The same cruelty extends to lobsters and shrimp, which are torn apart or boiled alive for “freshness.” Diners often laugh as the animals struggle on the plate, unaware—or indifferent—that the display comes at the cost of unbearable suffering5.

Compassion Must Guide Food Policy

New York prides itself on progressive values and innovative food policy. Yet this gap in regulation allows acts of violence against animals to masquerade as cultural tradition or culinary experience. The truth is simple: no taste justifies this level of cruelty. Freshness can be achieved without inflicting suffering on living creatures.

Activists and scientists alike are clear: serving live animals is a practice that belongs in the past. Other cities and countries have moved to restrict or ban such treatment. New York has the chance to lead by closing the loophole and making compassion a standard in its restaurants.

Act Now for a More Humane Future

Every day this continues, more animals endure agony under the guise of entertainment. It is time for New York City to act. By banning the serving of live animals in restaurants, city leaders can align policy with science, compassion, and public expectation. This change would not only protect animals but also affirm New York’s standing as a place where humanity guides progress.

Join us in calling on the New York City Department of Health and the Mayor’s Office of Food Policy to ban this cruel practice once and for all. Sign the petition today.

More on this issue:

  1. Gene Apodaca, NY1 (1 June 2017), "PETA Wants Flushing Restaurant to Stop Serving 'Live Seafood'."
  2. Jon Sufrin, The Globe and Mail (3 March 2015), "Diners Face Unique Experience, Moral Dilemma With Live Food."
  3. Staff Writer, Animal Agriculture and Climate Change (2021), "New York Restaurant Serves Live Octopuses to Customers."
  4. PETA Staff, PETA (17 August 2015, updated 2 Apr 2024), "An Ethical Restaurant Revolution: Will Restaurants Stop Serving Octopus?."
  5. PETA Investigations, PETA (September 2016), "Live-Animal Eating Exposed."

The Petition

To the Commissioner of the New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene (NYC Health), and the Mayor’s Office of Food Policy (MOFP),

New York City prides itself on being a leader in culture, progress, and compassion. Yet within its borders, restaurants continue to serve live animals, including octopuses, lobsters, and shrimp, in dishes where they are cut apart or boiled alive for the sake of spectacle. This practice is cruel, unnecessary, and inconsistent with the values of a city that champions both innovation and humane treatment of all living beings.

Scientific evidence shows that octopuses and crustaceans are intelligent, sentient creatures capable of feeling pain and stress. Octopuses demonstrate tool use, memory, and problem-solving skills. Lobsters and crabs exhibit wound guarding and defensive behaviors, clear indicators of their ability to suffer. Serving them alive reduces these remarkable animals to entertainment props, forcing them to endure prolonged agony in front of laughing diners.

Chefs and restaurant owners may argue that live service is a matter of tradition or freshness. But no culinary experience can justify the deliberate infliction of suffering. The claim that these animals are already dead when tentacles or limbs continue to writhe does not erase the fact that they are killed in brutal ways, often hacked apart moments before serving. In many cases, they remain alive until every usable part has been removed. This is not “freshness”—it is cruelty for profit.

New York City has long been a model for progressive food policy, from healthier school meals to sustainability initiatives. Now it has the opportunity to lead once more by outlawing the serving of live animals in all restaurants. This step would align with growing global recognition of the need to extend compassion to all sentient beings and set a powerful example for other cities to follow.

We call on NYC Health and the Mayor’s Office of Food Policy to take immediate action to ban this practice, close the legal gap that currently allows it, and enforce standards that reflect both ethical responsibility and public sentiment.

By ending the serving of live animals in New York City restaurants, we take a meaningful step toward ensuring a more humane, ethical, and compassionate future for all.

Sincerely,

Sponsor This Petition To Increase Impact

Sponsor This Petition To Increase Impact

$3.00
$3.00
Sale Sold out
View full details