Woman's 'Worst Fear Comes True' When Horse Falls Into Frozen Pond
Guest Contributor
When Ali Ernst returned to her upstate New York farm earlier this week, she was met with a scene that would terrify any animal owner. One of her horses, a beloved companion named Sly, had wandered onto a frozen pond on the property. From her window, Ernst could see him standing on the ice—unaware of the danger beneath his hooves. Within moments, the ice gave way, plunging Sly into the frigid water. It was a moment Ernst later described as one of her worst fears coming true.

This chilling incident, which could have ended in tragedy, instead became a story of quick thinking, community support, and a horse’s remarkable resilience. The harrowing experience of a horse falling through ice is every farm owner’s nightmare, and in this case, it was a situation that unfolded in real time. As Ernst scrambled to get help, she accidentally took a photo of Sly in the water—a haunting image that she feared might be her last of him.
According to her account shared with The Dodo, Ernst wasted no time. She alerted family and friends, and reached out to local emergency services. What followed was a coordinated effort by neighbors, police, and firefighters, all working together to save Sly from the icy pond. Body camera footage released by the Saratoga Springs Police Department captured the dramatic rescue, showing just how close the situation came to a devastating outcome.
Fortunately, Sly was pulled from the water in time. He was immediately transported to Rood & Riddle Equine Hospital, where he was treated for hypothermia. Despite the trauma and the cold, Sly showed no signs of lasting harm. Ernst later shared that he had made a full recovery and was back home, safe and healthy. “Sly is home and fine!” she said, expressing her gratitude for the overwhelming support she received.
The story of a horse rescued from an icy pond has resonated with many, not only for its emotional intensity but also for the way it highlights the strength of community. In a matter of minutes, people came together to save an animal in distress—a reminder of the compassion and quick action that can make all the difference in emergencies. I found this detail striking: even in a moment of panic, Ernst had the clarity to mobilize help, and her community responded without hesitation.
While the experience was undoubtedly traumatic, it has prompted Ernst to consider new safety measures to prevent future incidents. She acknowledged that Sly’s curiosity led him into danger, but also recognized the need for barriers or other deterrents to keep horses away from frozen water. It’s a lesson many rural property owners may take to heart as winter conditions continue to pose risks for outdoor animals.
In a light-hearted note, Ernst joked that Sly’s “dreams of being an Olympic figure skater are over,” but the relief in her words was unmistakable. The ordeal could have ended very differently, and her horse’s survival is a testament to the power of swift action and community solidarity. Stories like this one not only underscore the importance of preparedness but also celebrate the deep bonds between humans and animals.
The rescue of Sly from a frozen pond is a vivid example of how a potentially tragic event can turn into a story of hope and recovery. For those who care for animals—whether on farms, in shelters, or at home—it’s a powerful reminder of how quickly things can change, and how vital it is to act decisively when danger arises. Thanks to the efforts of many, Sly’s journey ended not in loss, but in life.