Illinois lawmakers have introduced a bill that may reshape the future of animal shelter practices.

House Bill 2410 seeks to restrict euthanasia at animal shelters to only a few circumstances. The bill proposes to amend existing laws so that euthanasia is allowed only when an animal suffers from health issues, displays severe behavioral problems, or exhibits dangerous aggressiveness. Lawmakers believe this measure will protect pets from unnecessary procedures while prompting shelters to explore alternative care options.

The bill was filed by Representative Barbara Hernandez. It amends provisions in the Animal Welfare Act, the Humane Care for Animals Act, and the Humane Euthanasia in Animal Shelters Act. Under HB2410, no person can euthanize a dog, cat, or other pet in a shelter unless the animal meets one of the specified conditions.

The measure is slated to become effective on January 1, 2026, following its passage.

Photo: Pexels

Lawmakers in Illinois have proposed a ban on routine shelter euthanasia. 

Legislative Details and Rationale

HB2410 states that euthanasia cannot be a routine solution for shelter overcrowding or financial constraints. Instead, it should be considered only for pressing issues such as severe illness or dangerous behavior.

“I want to make sure we protect them from unfortunate surgeries,” Representative Hernandez told The Center Square. The measure intends to refocus shelter operations on saving lives rather than reducing numbers through euthanasia.

Photo: Pexels

The proposal aims to protect pets from unnecessary procedures.

Animal Welfare and Shelter Capacity

Animal welfare experts have offered mixed views on the potential effects of the bill. Some argue that restricting euthanasia may lead shelters to struggle with space and resource management. In previous legislative proposals, similar measures led to warnings about shelter overcrowding. For example, officials from no-kill shelters have expressed concern that a blanket restriction on euthanasia could cause facilities to become overrun if they cannot manage the steady influx of animals.

“If this bill passes right now without fixing what is being created, it's like putting a plug on the end of a pipe but you just keep filling it,” Ronna Robertson, president of a no-kill shelter, Homeward Bound Waggin', told KHQA.

Animal control advocates emphasize that euthanasia remains an essential tool. Lauren Malmberg from the Illinois Animal Control Association pointed out that shelters use euthanasia in limited cases to ease suffering in animals that are chronically ill or dangerously aggressive. She noted that the live-release rate in Illinois shelters remains high, with euthanasia accounting for less than 10% of intakes.

Malmberg told WMAY that a shift away from euthanasia without alternative solutions could drive up operational costs and strain resources.

Photo: Pexels

The proposal may lead to new adoption strategies.

Balancing Compassion with Practicality

Supporters of HB2410 stress that the measure is not an absolute ban on euthanasia. Instead, it seeks to narrow its application to cases where it is medically or behaviorally justified. The intention is to safeguard healthy animals from losing their chance at a loving home. This approach contrasts with earlier proposals that called for a total ban, which many critics argued would worsen shelter crowding and compromise animal welfare overall.

Critics of previous similar bills, such as Senate Bill 3791, argued that banning euthanasia entirely could force shelters to turn away animals in need. They highlighted that some euthanasia is sometimes necessary to prevent prolonged suffering in animals that do not have a realistic chance of recovery or safe rehoming.

By permitting euthanasia under strict conditions, HB2410 attempts to strike a balance between compassion and the harsh realities of shelter management, KFVS12 reports.

Photo: Pexels

The future of Illinois shelter practices now hangs in the balance.

Looking Ahead: The Future of Shelter Practices

The debate over HB2410 reflects broader concerns over pet care and animal control in Illinois. Shelter directors and animal welfare advocates must now plan for a future where euthanasia is used sparingly. The legislation could prompt shelters to invest more in adoption programs, foster care networks, and enhanced veterinary care. Lawmakers hope that by limiting euthanasia, the state will encourage more humane practices and improve long-term outcomes for shelter animals.

As Illinois navigates these changes, the future of animal shelters hangs in the balance. Lawmakers must consider the practical implications of HB2410 and work with local communities to ensure that any new policy supports both animal welfare and shelter capacity.